Classical Education: Loving the Rock of Reality



"Why Latin? Why Logic? Why only 'great' books?" 

Such are the questions levied at the classicist. They are good questions, but the best answers are not found in pragmatics, a list of the benefits of a classical education. Instead, the reason anyone ultimately prefers a classical approach to education is that she holds to a classical worldview. I say 'ultimately' because pragmatic answers don't count for nothing. One cannot help using them in class to garner support for Latin verb endings. "Throughout history, the best authors were great Latinists" I said the other day. I had in mind one student whose mother had told me that she would like to be a writer. Motivating a student to say 'amō, amās, amat..." thirty times a day is one thing, but adopting a clear reason for committing oneself to the classical project is quite another. To do that, one needs to off one's modern viewpoint and lean into the worldview of a classicist. One can be inconsistent for some desired good, but it is better to attempt to line up one's assumptions about the world and follow their trail.

In The Mirror of Language, Marcia Colish describes it well:

Most of the classical philosophers whom the Middle Ages knew and regarded as authoritative held that there was an objective order of being prior to the subjective order of knowing. Following their lead, medieval philosophers endorsed the idea of an epistemology grounded in and controlled by its objects of knowledge with equal assurance and vigor. And, notwithstanding the scholastic demand  for a theory of cognition explaining man's knowledge of the world of nature, the object to which medieval thinkers normally addressed themselves was the world of spiritual reality, with preeminent attention to God. The medieval theory of knowledge was a direct consequence of this radically ontological emphasis. Epistemology was conceived as a function of metaphysics. The existence of an objective order of being was the primary condition which was held to make human thought possible at all. Furthermore, medieval thinkers identified being par excellence with the God of the Bible. Thus, they held, the Being of God Himself was the guarantee, the criterion, and the conditio sine qua non of whatever men might know about him, or about anything else (Marcia Colish, The Mirror of Language: A Study in the Medieval Theory of Knowledge. 1968, 1).

In sum, human thought is possible only if there is an objective order of being including God as the ultimate being. If the world exhibits objective order, then the content of our classes ought to be determined by it. Note that the classical worldview begins with God, then moves to created reality, and finally arrives at our ability to know anything.

In contrast, those who followed educational theorist and father of modern education, John Dewey, began with the knower and then asked how education might induce his flourishing. Dewey compared the classical way with a rock. It is static and immovable. Instead, he insisted, education is more like a plant, an ever adapting organism that, given the right environment, will flourish. In his view, unless what you are teaching connects with what a student experiences, it won't aid flourishing.

Dewey characterizes the difference accurately. The idea driving a classicist is that the body of knowledge we are responsible for is largely unchanging. It grows over time like a library, but it is not revolutionized for the sake of progress. It is rocklike in the sense that a student should knock up against it. It is solid. This is a way of saying that the content of one's class serves as the measure of things. To be committed to the classical project is to love the rock!

According to the classicist, language functions to mediate reality to human beings. Since reality is ordered by God, then reality is fundementally normative. Such normativity entails a static (and growing) body of knowledge obtained through the careful use of the powers of human learning. Language serves as the means by which one is able to access reality:

"The symbolic theory of knowledge developed in the Middle Ages was cast in terms of the relationship between words, on the one hand, and reality, on the other. It was the attempt of medieval men to reflect, in the mirror of the trivium, what they believed to be the one normative epistemological relationship between man and God." (4)

Words function to point to reality. If reality is an ordered reality governed by God, then words don't take on a pragmatic function in education. Rather, they reflect ('as in a mirror') the that reality. Again, this entails the unchanging nature 'body' of knowledge. Since the very nature of reality remains the same, so does what is said about it:

"The object of knowledge always remains the yardstick against which any statement about it must be measured. Statements are thus held not to be heuristic, or productive of knowledge in the first instance, but expressive of a knowledge of already existing in the mind of the knower. Axiomatic to this epistemology is the assurance of the subject's anterior knowledge of the object, a knowledge indispensable for his recognition of the truth of the words expressing it... The word of the speaker, although it cannot produce knowledge of the object, can point to it if it is not already in the mind of the subject. If the subject already knows the object, the word of the speaker can recall it to him, making it vividly present in his mind." (5)
Colish rehearses the views of Augustine, Anselm, Aquinas, and Dante showing how each one developed a theory of language to reflect the normative nature of words, definitions, grammar, and logic.  

13 comments:

reginald surict said...

Understanding of interview essay writing and its kinds is important for education and future career. Learn more about it here.

chindi chor said...

Thanks for just one marvelous publishing! I savored reading it; you are a great publisher.I will make sure you bookmark your site and may keep coming back someday. I wish to encourage that you keep up your great articles, have a good weekend!
Neet 2018
TS EAMCET 2018
Jee Main 2018

Jassi said...

Candidates the JEE MAIN SYLLABUS 2018 PDF DOWNLOAD is now ready, you can download it from a given link at the bottom of this article, for JEE MAIN 2018 syllabus visit here and for JEE ADVANCED 2018 Syllabus visit here.

Muhammad Saqlain said...

JEE Main Result 2018
JEE Main Result 2018 CBSE
IIT JEE Main Result 2018
JEE Main Rank Card 2018 Download
CBSE JEE Main 2018 Result
GATE 2018 Result Date
GATE 2018 Results
GATE 2018 Score Card Download
GATE 2018 Results
GATE Result 2018
TN HSC Result 2018
TN Plus Two Result 2018
TN Board 12th Result 2018
Tamilnadu HSC Result 2018
TN HSC 12th Class Result 2018
TN SSLC Result 2018
TN 10th Result 2018
Tamilnadu Board Result 2018
Tamil Nadu SSLC 10th Result 2018
TN SSLC Result 2018
AP SSC Results 2018
AP 10th Results 2018
Manabadi SSC Results 2018
Schools9 SSC Results 2018
SSC Results 2018 Andhra Pradesh

Muhammad Saqlain said...

ISC Result 2018
ISC 12th Result 2018
CISCE 12th Result 2018
ISC Board Result 2018
ISC Result 2018 Class 12
GSEB SSC Result 2018
GSEB 10th Result 2018
Gujarat SSC Result 2018
Gujarat Board 10th Result 2018
GSEB SSC 10th Class Result 2018
JAC 10th Result 2018
JAC Matric Result 2018
Jharkhand 10th Result 2018
JAC Result 2018 Class 10
JAC Board Result 2018
GSEB HSC Result 2018
GSEB 12th Result 2018
Gujarat HSC Result 2018
Gujarat 12th Class Result 2018
GSEB Result 2018 Class 12
HBSE 10th Result 2018
HBSE Matric Result 2018
HBSE Result 2018 Class 10
Haryana Board 10th Result 2018
Haryana HBSE Result 2018

Muhammad Saqlain said...

RBSE Result 2018 Class 10
RBSE 10th Result 2018
Rajasthan 10th Result 2018
Raj Board 10th Result 2018
Rajasthan Board 10th Result 2018
BSEB 12th Result 2018
BSEB Intermediate Result 2018
Bihar Board 12th Result 2018
Bihar Intermediate Result 2018
BSEB 12th Class Result 2018
WBCHSE HS Result 2018
WB HS Result 2018
WBCHSE 12th Result 2018
West Bengal Higher Secondary Result 2018
WBCHSE Result 2018 HS
ICSE 10th Result 2018
ICSE Result 2018 Class 10
CISCE ICSE Result 2018
ICSE Board Result 2018
ICSE Results 2018
PSEB 10th Result 2018
PSEB Result 2018 Class 10
Punjab 10th Result 2018
Punjab Board Matric Result 2018
PSEB Board Result 2018

Muhammad Saqlain said...

HBSE 12th Result 2018
HBSE Plus Two Result 2018
Haryana Board 12th Result 2018
HBSE Result 2018 Class 12
Haryana Board Result 2018
CGBSE 10th Result 2018
CGBSE Matric Result 2018
CG Board 10th Result 2018
CG 10th Result 2018
Chhattisgarh 10th Result 2018
AP EAMCET Results 2018
AP EAMCET Results 2018 Manabadi
AP EAMCET 2018 Results
AP EAMCET Rank Card 2018 Download
Manabadi EAMCET Results 2018
CBSE 12th Result 2018
CBSE Result 2018 Class 12
CBSE Plus Two Result 2018
CBSE Board Result 2018
CBSE 12th Result 2018
CGBSE 12th Result 2018
CGBSE Result 2018 Class 12
CG Board 12th Result 2018
CG 12th Class Result 2018
Chhattisgarh Board 12th 2018

Muhammad Saqlain said...

Odisha 10th Result 2018
Odisha HSC Result 2018
BSE Odisha Result 2018
Odisha Matric Result 2018
Odisha HSC 10th Result 2018
Kerala HSE Result 2018
Kerala +2 Result 2018
DHSE Kerala Result 2018
Kerala Plus Two Result 2018
Kerala 12th Result 2018
MP Board 12th Result 2018
MP Board HSSC Result 2018
MPBSE 12th Class Result 2018
MP Board Result 2018 12th Class
Madhya Pradesh Board 12th Result 2018
Kerala SSLC Result 2018
Kerala 10th Result 2018
SSLC Result 2018 Kerala Board
Kerala SSLC 10th Result 2018
Kerala Board Matric Result 2018
HPBOSE 12th Result 2018
HPBOSE Plus Two Result 2018
HP Board 12th Result 2018
HPBOSE Result 2018 Class 12
HP Board +2 Result 2018

Muhammad Saqlain said...

MP Board 10th Result 2018
MP Board HSC Result 2018
MPBSE 10th Result 2018
MPBSE Result 2018 10th HSC
Madhya Pradesh Board 10th Result 2018
UP Board 10th Result 2018
UP Board Highschool Result 2018
UP Highschool Result 2018
UP Board Matric Result 2018
UP Board Result 2018 10th Class
WB Madhyamik Result 2018
WB 10th Result 2018
Madhyamik Result 2018 West Bengal
WB Madhyamik Result 2018
WB Board 10th Class Result 2018
UP Board 12th Result 2018
UP Board Intermediate Result 2018
UP Intermediate Result 2018
UP Board Result 2018 12th Class
Uttar Pradesh Board 12th Result 2018
CBSE 10th Result 2018
CBSE Result 2018 Class 10
CBSE Results 2018
CBSE 10th Result 2018 Region Wise
CBSE 10th Result 2018 School Wise

Muhammad Saqlain said...

PUC Result 2018 Karnataka
Karnataka 2nd PUC Result 2018
2nd PUC Result 2018
Karnataka PUC Result 2018 Exam
Karnataka PUC 2nd Year Result 2018
SSC Result 2018 Maharashtra
Maharashtra 10th Result 2018
Maharashtra Board Result 2018
Maharashtra 10th Class Board Result 2018
SSC 10th Result 2018 Maharashtra Board
Maharashtra Board HSC Result 2018
Maharashtra 12th Result
Maharashtra Board Result 2018
Maharashtra HSC 12th Result 2018
HSC 12th Result 2018 Maharashtra Board
Bihar Board 10th Result 2018
Bihar Board Matric Result 2018
BSEB 10th Result 2018
BSEB Matric Result 2018
Bihar Board Result 2018 10th Class
Karnataka SSLC Result 2018
Karnataka 10th Result 2018
Karnataka SSLC 10th Result 2018
SSLC Result 2018 Karnataka
SSLC 10th Result 2018 Karnataka Board

Muhammad Saqlain said...

AP Inter Results 2018
AP Intermediate Results 2018
AP Inter 2nd Year Results 2018
AP Inter 1st Year Results 2018
AP Inter Results 2018 Manabadi
TS Intermediate Results 2018
TS Inter Results 2018
TS Inter 1st Year Results 2018
TS Inter 2nd Year Results 2018
TS Inter Results 2018 Manabadi
Telangana 10th Results 2018
TS 10th Results 2018
Telangana SSC Results 2018
Manabadi SSC Results 2018
TS SSC Results 2018
NEET Result 2018
NEET PG Result 2018
NEET UG Result 2018
NEET 2018 Results
NEET 2018 Exam Result
TS EAMCET Results 2018
Telangana EAMCET Results 2018
TS EAMCET Rank Card 2018
TS EAMCET Results 2018 Manabadi
Schools9 TS EAMCET Result 2018

Muhammad Saqlain said...

Gujarat Election Results 2017
Gujarat Vidha Sabha Results 2017
Gujarat Election Exit Poll Results
Gujarat Election 2017 Result
Gujarat Election 2017
Himachal Pradesh Election Results 2017
HP Election Results 2017
HP Election Exit Poll Results
HP Election 2017 Result
HP Election 2017
Eid Mubarak Images 2018
Eid Mubarak 2018
Eid Mubarak Quotes 2018
Eid Mubarak Wallpapers 2018
Eid Mubarak Wishes 2018
Assam HSLC Result 2018
Assam 10th Result 2018
Assam Board Result 2018
SEBA HSLC Result 2018
SEBA 10th HSLC Result 2018
Fathers Day Images 2018
Fathers Day Wallpapers 2018
Fathers Day Quotes 2018
Fathers Day Sayings 2018
Fathers Day Gift Ideas 2018

Education Information Portal said...

Superb article. Thank u so much for sharing with us.
GATE Exam 2018

NEET Exam Preparation Tips

JEE Main 2018 Notification

Kanpur University Entrance Exam Form

Top Ten colleges in India